Continuous Improvement for LLM Applications
Continuous improvement is a crucial aspect of developing and maintaining high-quality LLM applications. This guide will walk you through the process of evaluating and improving your LLM-powered systems over time.Collaborative Flow on Literal AI
Evaluation Framework
Before implementing continuous improvement, it’s essential to establish a robust evaluation framework. Follow these steps to create an effective evaluation process:Determine the Evaluation Level
Choose the appropriate level for evaluation:- LLM call level (similar to unit tests)
- Agent run level (similar to integration tests)
- Conversation level
Define Evaluation Metrics
Identify what aspects of your LLM application you want to measure:- Hallucination rate
- Answer relevancy
- Application-specific behaviors
- Response quality
- Task completion rate
Select Evaluation Methods
Choose one or more evaluation methods based on your needs:- LLM-as-a-Judge: Use another LLM to evaluate outputs
- Code-based evaluation: Implement programmatic checks
- Hybrid approach: Combine LLM and code-based evaluations
- Embedding similarity: Compare vector representations of responses
- Human review: Incorporate manual evaluation by experts
Improvement Process
Once you have established your evaluation framework, follow these steps to continuously improve your LLM application:Pre-production Iteration
- Create a dataset with ground truth examples
- Implement your evaluation procedure
- Iterate on your LLM application (prompts, code, etc.) to improve performance
- Build and test the first production-ready version
Production Monitoring and Evaluation
Now that you have a production system, implement the following strategies to gather data and improve your application in production:Product Feedback Loops
- Implicit feedback: Track user actions (e.g., accepting or rejecting suggestions)
- Explicit feedback: Implement user rating systems (e.g., thumbs up/down)
Human Review
- Regularly have human experts review a subset of logged interactions using annotation queues
- Identify areas for improvement and edge cases
Automated AI Evaluations
- Implement reference-free evaluations to continuously monitor performance
- Use metrics like perplexity, coherence, or task-specific scores
Continuous Improvement Cycle
- Analyze data from production monitoring
- Identify edge cases and areas for improvement
- Add new examples to your evaluation dataset
- Update prompts, agent code, or model fine-tuning
- Run tests to ensure improvements don’t introduce regressions
- Deploy the new version to production
CI/CD Integration
To ensure that there are no regressions, integrate the following test into your CI/CD pipeline:- Pull the most representative dataset
- Run the LLM system and the evaluations
- Pull the baseline performance metrics with regards to that dataset
- Compare results to the baseline metrics using a confidence interval
Global Performance Monitoring
Track product metrics such as:- Conversion rates
- User retention
- Task completion rates
- User satisfaction scores